The Buddhist Self: On Tathagatagarbha and Atman

The assertion that there is nothing in the constitution of any person that deserves to be considered the self (atman) - a permanent, unchanging kernel of personal identity in this life and those to come - has been a cornerstone of Buddhist teaching from its inception. Whereas other Indian religious systems celebrated the search for and potential discovery of one's "true self," Buddhism taught about the futility of searching for anything in our experience that is not transient and ephemeral. But a small yet influential set of Mahayana Buddhist texts, composed in India in the early centuries CE, taught that all sentient beings possess at all times, and across their successive lives, the enduring and superlatively precious nature of a Buddha. This was taught with reference to the enigmatic expression tathagatagarbha - the "womb" or "chamber" for a Buddha - which some texts refer to as a person's true self. The Buddhist Self is a methodical examination of Indian teaching about the tathagatagarbha (otherwise the presence of one's "Buddha-nature") and the extent to which different Buddhist texts and authors articulated this in terms of the self. C. V. Jones attends to each of the Indian Buddhist works responsible for explaining what is meant by the expression tathagatagarbha, and how far this should be understood or promoted using the language of selfhood. With close attention to these sources, Jones argues that the trajectory of Buddha-nature thought in India is also the history and legacy of a Buddhist account of what deserves to be called the self: an innovative attempt to equip Mahayana Buddhism with an affirmative response to wider Indian interest in the discovery of something precious or even divine in one's own constitution. This argument is supplemented by critical consideration of other themes that run through this distinctive body of Mahayanist literature: the relationship between Buddhist and non-Buddhist teachings about the self, the overlap between the tathagatagarbha and the nature of the mind, and the originally radical position that the only means of becoming liberated from rebirth is to achieve the same exalted status as the Buddha.

About the Author :
C. V. Jones is an affiliated lecturer of the Divinity Faculty and Bye-Fellow of Selwyn College, University of Cambridge.

Review :
C. V. Jones' landmark work deals with Buddhist ātmavāda, which was regarded as "taboo" by authentic Buddhist traditions yet furnished a bridge between Buddhists and non-Buddhist doctrines. His solid philological and philosophical study sheds new light on this ambivalent attitude in Mahāyāna Buddhism and proposes insightful solutions to puzzles at pivotal turning points in the history of Buddhism in India during the first half of the first millennium.--Kazuo Kano, Komazawa University This rich book breaks new ground in the study of tathāgatagarbha doctrine, a major strand of Mahāyāna Buddhism. Wielding an impressive command over a difficult primary literature in three classical languages, C. V. Jones argues cogently for nothing short of a revised chronology of the core corpus of tathāgatagarbha scriptures and of the thought it contains. He also adopts a heuristic focus on the scandalous claim that tathāgatagarbha can rightly be understood as a type of true "self" (ātman). Jones thus confronts head-on aspects of the doctrine most controversial in both Buddhist traditions and modern scholarship alike, and uses this problematic as a window through which to gain a fresh perspective on relations between Buddhism and other bodies of Indian religious thought and literature. His book will surely take a place as one of a handful of principal studies of this dimension of Buddhism.--Michael Radich, Heidelberg University