Komar/Melamid: Two Soviet Dissident Artists

The state of the Soviet artist, summed up by Solzhenitsyn in The First Circle--"agreat writer is, so to speak, a second gov­ernment of his country"--is exemplified by the two dissident artists' parodies of state art collected here for the first time. The fate of Vitali Komar and Aleksandr Melamid, who only recently were al­lowed to immigrate to Israel, is well known to art critics and historians, if only from the extensive reviews of the shows of their paintings at the Feldman Gallery in New York in 1976 and 1977. An in-depth discussion of the paint­ings and of the background of Soviet dissident art is provided by Jack Burnham, chairman of the Department of Art at Northwestern University, in his scholarly Introduction, "Paradox and Politics: The Art of Komar and Mela­mid." For the uninitiated, the Komar-Mela­mid paintings (their work is a collabora­tive effort) no doubt will be a surprise and a delight: it is at once sprightly, intricate, and mystical. Called "Sots" art (for Socialist art), it is a kind of Pop that parodies the propaganda posters and street banners designed for public con­sumption by Russian officialdom. The Sots subjects from the first show include the stern head of a worker holding his finger to his lips and entitled "Don't Babble," several banners with such slogans as "Glory to Labor" and "Our Goal Communism," and a painting of a "Laika" cigarette pack using as its em­blem the Soviet dog sent into orbit with "Sputnik II" in 1957. But Pop is only a part of these versa­tile artists' repertory. From the second show, especially noteworthy are "Fac­tory for the Production of Blue Smoke," an Arcadian scene with mystical as well as social significance; the complex "TransState," the artists' creation of a unique form of internationalism open to any person in the world dissatisfied with his own country; and the magical "Fare­well to Russia."

Review :
“A book with relevance extending beyond the narrow limits of art history and art criticism. Recommended.”—Choice “Komar/Melamid’s art is an amusing and intelligent commentary on both Communist and capitalist trends: the USSR’s excess of propaganda, the ram­pant consumerism in the West. The artists are the proponents of, among other things, a style they call ‘Sots’—Soviet pop art. The long essays that be­gin the book may help to make clear to Westerners why their art, which seems far from outré to us, is considered so subversive in their native land. An en­lightening and entertaining study.”— Library Journal “An in-depth discussion of the paint­ings of Soviet dissident art is pro­vided by Jack Burnham.”—Judaica Book News   “Few works by dissidents are available in reproduction yet; this is worth see­ing.”—Washington International Arts Letter   “Their [Komar and Melamid’s] touch is brilliantly cool and ironic, their satire and iconoclasm not tied to any ideology other than one of creative expression.”—Amy Newman, ARTnews,April 1976