History and Theory: Contemporary Readings

The last twenty-five years have witnessed a real revolution in our understanding of history. During this period the "linguistic turn" occurred (with its emphasis on the rhetoric of history and the topics of narrative, the poetics of historical representation, the political dimensions of history, the inclusion of dispossessed groups as subjects of history, and insights gleaned from postmodernism and feminism). This "turn" itself inspired spirited criticisms as well as attempts to appropriate its insights into a new account of history. This book brings together some of the most important essays in the theory of history which have produced this revolution and the responses to it. The book is organized into categories designed to capture the implications of the linguistic turn, and within these categories to provide essays which speak directly to one another. These categories include: Narrativity; Writing and Reading History; Realism, Constructivism, and Beyond; Postmodernism and the Theory of History; Representation and Trauma; Gender, Sexuality, and Sex; and Objectivity. Every effort has been made to include only essays that are clear and accessible. The essays were selected not only because of their philosophical depth but also because they develop their points by way of actual historical examples and practices in the discipline. In all of this the aim of the editors has been to make available to those interested in the nature of history recent significant reflections on this topic which arise out of historical practice and which return readers to it enlightened and revivified.

Table of Contents:
Introduction. Part I: Narrativity:1. Hayden White, 'The Historical Text as Literary Artefact'. 2. Noel Carroll, 'Interpretation, History, and Narrative'. Part II: Writing and Reading History:3. The Rhetoric of History: Jack Hexter. 4. Making Up Lost Time: Writing on the Writing of History: Nancy Partner. 5. History, Language, and Reading: Waiting for Crillon: Dominick LaCapra. Part III: Realism, Constructivism and Beyond:6. History and Fiction as Modes of Comprehension: Louis Mink. 7. Narrative and the Real World: An Argument for Continuity: David Carr. 8. Telling It Like It Was: Historical Narratives on Their Own Terms: Andrew Norman. Part IV: Post-Modernism and the Theory of History:9. Historiography and Postmodernism: Frank Ankersmit. 10. Historiography and Postmodernism: Reconsiderations: Perez Azgorin. 11. Reply to Professor Zagorin: Frank Ankersmit. Part V: Representation and Trauma:12. 'Never Again' is Now: Hans Kellner. 13. Is It Possible to Misrepresent the Holocaust? : Berel Lang. Part VI: Gender, Sexuality, Sex:14. Is There a History of Sexuality? : David Halperin. 15. No Sex, No Gender: Nancy Partner. Part VII: Objectivity:16. Objectivity is Not Neutrality: Rhetoric vs Practice in Peter Novick's That Noble Dream: Thomas Haskell. 17. Objectivity and Truth in History: J. L. Gorman. 18. Historical Knowledge and Historical Reality: A Plea for Internal Realism: Chris Lorenz. 19. Progress in Historical Studies: Raymond Martin.

About the Author :
Brian Fay is Chair of the Philosophy department at Wesleyan University. Previous books include: Social Theory and Political Practice, Critical Social Science, and Contemporary Philosophy of Social Science: A Multi-cultural Approach, all published by Blackwell. Professor Fay's research concentrates on questions surrounding the nature of social inquiry and its relation to politics and ethics. He is Executive Editor of the journal History and Theory, published by Blackwell (US). Philip Pomper is William F. Armstrong Professor of History at Wesleyan University. Professor Pomper applies psychology to history. Aside from a general study of the Russian revolutionary movement, he has written biographies of leading revolutionaries. He has also investigated psychoanalytic theories of history in his book, The Structure of Mind in History and serves as Associate Editor for History and Theory. Richard T. Vann is Professor of History and Professor of Letters at Wesleyan University. He has written on English social and intellectual history and on the logic and rhetoric of historiography. He is Senior Editor of History and Theory.

Review :
"A genuinely helpful introduction to the two questions of narrativity and objectivity." History Today