Marxism and Workers' Self-Management: The Essential Tension

This book comes to terms with Marxism and its relationship to workers' self-management. David L. Prychitko offers a reinterpretation of Marx's vision of socialism by arguing that Marx's understanding of the praxis-nature of humankind led him to a utopian goal of decentralized socialism based on the total abolition of market exchange. The full development of workers' self-management of industry was to be accompanied by comprehensive planning of the socially owned means of production. Prychitko takes modern economists to task for paying too little attention to the implications of Marx's praxis philosophy and to the organizational consequences of abolishing private ownership and the market process. This abolition leads inevitably, he argues, to the development of hierarchical structures of state domination and power. This tension between democratic decentralization--workers' self-management--and central economic planning--which tends to destroy meaningful self-management--can be traced back to Marx himself. The failure of state socialism in Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union has not dissuaded those who wish to keep Marx alive from pushing workers' self-management as a feasible enterprise in a free market system. Prychitko's volume does more than simply interpret the meaning of Marxism. It analyzes the tension between centralization and decentralization in contemporary theory and practice. The contemporary theory of self-managed socialism, put to much use in Yugoslavia, is critically assessed by Prychitko. After focusing on a case study of American barrel-making cooperatives that managed to compete well with traditional capitalist firms and survive an extraordinary degree of market competition, Prychitko concludes the book by speculating over the feasibility of worker-managed firms in a truly dynamic, rivalrous market setting. Marxism and Workers' Self-Management will be of great interest to scholars of Marx, political economy, social theory, and labor studies.

Table of Contents:
Preface Introduction Marx, Utopia, and the Radical Milieu of the Nineteenth Century The Essential Tension: Praxis, Cooperation, and Comprehensive Planning in Marxian Socialism Cooperation, Calculation, and Centralization: The Critique of Comprehensive Planning The Neoclassical Debate Over Incentives in the Self-Managed Enterprise Self-Management and the Knowledge Problem: Tensions in the Theory and Practice of Yugoslav Socialism Worker Cooperatives within a Market Process: Lessons from the Cooperage Cooperatives of Minneapolis, 1864-1929 Conclusion Bibliography Index

About the Author :
DAVID L. PRYCHITKO is Associate Professor in the Department of Economics at the State University of New York at Oswego. He specializes in political economy and comparative systems studies and has written articles for Critical Review, Global Economic Policy, and Methodus.