Virtue, Rules, and Justice: Kantian Aspirations

Thomas E. Hill, Jr., interprets, explains, and extends Kant's moral theory in a series of essays that highlight its relevance to contemporary ethics. The book is divided into four sections. The first three essays cover basic themes: they introduce the major aspects of Kant's ethics; explain different interpretations of the Categorical Imperative; and sketch a 'constructivist' reading of Kantian normative ethics distinct from the Kantian constructivisms of Onora O'Neill and John Rawls. The next section is on virtue, and the essays collected here discuss whether it is a virtue to regard the natural environment as intrinsically valuable, address puzzles about moral weakness, contrast ideas of virtue in Kant's ethics and in 'virtue ethics,' and comment on duties to oneself, second-order duties, and moral motivation in Kant's Doctrine of Virtue. Four essays on moral rules propose human dignity as a guiding value for a system of norms rather than a self-standing test for isolated cases, contrast the Kantian perspectives on moral rules with rule-utilitarianism and then with Jonathan Dancy's moral particularism, and distinguish often-conflated questions about moral relativism. Hill goes on to outline a Kantian position on two central issues. In the last section of the book, three essays on practical questions show how a broadly Kantian theory, if critical of Kant's official theory of law, might re-visit questions about revolution, prison reform, and forcible interventions in other countries for humanitarian purposes. In the final essay, Hill develops the implications of Kant's Doctrine of Virtue for the responsibility of by-standers to oppression.

Table of Contents:
Acknowledgments General Introduction Abstracts 1. Basic themes 1: Kant's Ethical Theory: An Overview 2: Kantian Normative Ethics 3: Kantian Constructivism as Normative Ethics 2. Virtue 4: Finding Value in Nature 5: Kant on Weakness of Will 6: Kantian Virtue and 'Virtue Ethics' 7: Kant's Tugendlehre as Normative Ethics 3. Moral rules and principles 8: The Dignity of Persons: Kant, Problems, and a Proposal 9: Assessing Moral Rules: Utilitarian and Kantian Perspectives 10: The Importance of Moral Rules and Principles 11: Moral Construction as a Task: Sources and Limits 4. Practical Questions 12: Questions about Kant's Opposition to Revolution 13: Treating Criminals as Ends in Themselves 14: Kant and Humanitarian Intervention 15: Moral Responsibilities of Bystanders Bibliography Index

About the Author :
Thomas E. Hill, Jr., received an AB from Harvard College, a BPhil as a Rhodes Scholar from the University of Oxford, and a PhD from Harvard University. He is author of Autonomy and Self-Respect (CUP), Dignity and Practical Reason in Kant's Moral Theory (Cornell University Press), Respect, Pluralism, and Justice (OUP), and Human Welfare and Moral Worth (OUP). He edited the Blackwell Guide to Kant's Ethics (Wiley-Blackwell) and, with Arnulf Zweig, co-edited Kant's Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals (OUPs). He taught briefly at the Johns Hopkins University and Pomona College, at UCLA for sixteen years, as a visitor at Stanford University and the University of Minnesota, and is currently Kenan Professor in philosophy at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. His essays explore a wide range of topics in moral and political philosophy, with special interest in Kant and broadly Kantian perspectives on practical issues.

Review :
this collection has a great deal to offer to a large and diverse audience. ... Most of the book should engage philosophers interested in moral and political philosophy generally. The collection will be especially welcome to the many admirers of Hills own brand of Kantian constructivism or of his distinctive Kantian approach to investigating moral and political problems. Virtue, Rules, and Justice advances our understanding of core issues in moral philosophy. Overall, this book succeeds in two important ways. First, Hill provides an illuminative reading of many of the major aspects of Kants ethics and distinguishes both his own reading from those of other commentators and Kants ethics from other ethical theories...The second way in which Hill succeeds is in his expansion of Kants ethics and demonstration of how a broadly Kantian ethical theory can be applied to contemporary ethical problems. This is a relatively unique contribution to the literature. Few others have gone to such lengths to extend Kants ethical theory to highlight the contribution these theories can make to Philosophy in Review XXXIII (2013), no. 4 300 practical ethical issues. Hill also thoroughly and consistently identifies a variety of objections to his interpretations and defends himself against them.